BIGGEST FROGGY, BIGGEST POND
The Lew Burdette Story
"The greatest multiple-game pitching in a half century of World Series was contortionistically contrived by a fidgety, whipcordy West Virginian who used to be known as 'Froggy,' later was hailed as 'Squirrel,' and should now be known as 'Lion.'
Practical joking off the field has marked the 31 years of Selva Lewis Burdette, Jr. But on the mound the lanky righty is a cold, grim-lipped, steely-eyed performer, one with an amazing repertoire of sinker, screwball, knuckleball, curve, fast ball and who-knows-what-else.
It's that super-market repertoire, made especially lethal by near-perfect control, that carried the husky-voiced veteran to 4-2, 1-0 and 5-0 triumphs over the New York Yankees in the second, fifth and seventh games of the 1957 Series. This trinity plus Warren Spahn's 7-5 (ten-inning) fourth-game win, earned Milwaukee its glorious world laurels. Without Burdette, the Braves would have been dumped in five games.
Only four times before in all 54 World Series- and not since 1920- had a pitcher won three starts without an intermittent defeat. Only twice before- and not since 1905- had a pitcher shut out the opposition twice. And in blanking the Yanks twice, Burdette equalled the number of shutouts hung on the retiring champs by all American League pitchers throughout the regular 154-game season.
As one of the players remarked, 'A guy's gotta have a lot of 'belly' to do that.'
Consecutively, the rather gangling sidearmer pitched 24 shutout innings, 15 of them in the Yankees' own park. In his next World Series, he'll thus be in prime position to extend his scoreless skein beyond the record 29 2/3 by Babe Ruth (Red Sox, 1916-18) and the runnerup 28 1/3 by Christy Mathewson (Giants 1905-11).
Only Matty's three shutouts in as many starts against the 1905 Athletics outgleam Burdette's triad. The only challenger for all-time second-best could be Stan Coveleski. In 1920 the Cleveland spitballer beat Brooklyn three times, 3-1, 5-1, 3-0. While only one of his wins was a shutout, to Burdette's two, each of his games was a five-hitter (to Burdette's three seven-hitters) and he walked but two (to Burdette's four, one intentional). In his three wins Matty allowed 14 hits (two four-hitters, one six-hitter) and walked but one.
But whereas Matty and Coveleski started from scratch in the opening game, each of Burdette's wins came in a clutch contest. The Braves, having bowed to Whitey Ford, 3-1, in the opener, were one down before he scored his first victory. He won next in a spectacular 1-0 duel with Ford when a Yankee victory would have sent the American Leaguers home needing only one win in two games to retain their title. And finally, after the Braves had faltered again, 3-2, on the sixth afternoon, and with $3,000 a man at stake, he won the showdown game.
For the records, there were nine previous three-game World Series winners, but only four of them did it in complete games and without other defeat. Matty, Coveleski, Pittsburgh's Babe Adams over Detroit in 1909 (4-1, 8-4, 8-0) and the A's Jack Coombs over the Cubs in 1910 (9-3, 12-5, 7-2) had such a sweep. Two starting victories and a third in relief were accomplished by the White Sox' Red Faber against the 1917 Giants and the Cardinals' Harry Brecheen against the 1946 Red Sox. Pittsburgh's Deacon Phillipe and the Red Sox' Bill Dineen (who pitched two shutouts) won three each in the 1903 inaugural World Series, which went eight games, but Phillippe also lost two and Dineen one. The Red Sox' Smoky Joe Wood also lost one while winning three against the 1912 Giants, one in relief.
Accentuating Burdette's feats was the fact he took the mound distraught by an accident to his three-year-old Madge Rhea, whose sight was threatened by a rose thorn that had stuck in her eye. A third child, Mary Lou, was just a week old (son Lewis Kent is six) and Mary Ann Burdette whom Lew met at a Charleston bowling party in 1949, was just out of the hospital in Sarasota, Fla., where the family winters.
Paradoxically, Burdette's great inner control is encased in a jittery shell. He has been described as a man of a hundred motions and a thousand nerves, with a nervous pre-pitch dance of a toy monkey on a string. Before delivering a pitch, he rubs the back of his neck with his hand, tugs at the bill of his cap, takes off his glove, rubs the ball, rubs his forehead with his fingers, rubs his fingers on his uniform, licks his fingers, picks up the resin bag, smooths the dirt in front of the mound, turns around and looks at the outfield, and squeezes the ball a final time.
As Manager Fred Haney puts it, 'Burdette is the only man who can make coffee look nervous.'
Following his exaggerated antics, Burdette comes off the mound and onto the grass so fast that sometimes he appears it appears he's going to beat the ball to the plate.
All this started back in Nitro, West Virginia, November 22, 1926, where Lew was born the second of three boys and a girl to Agnes and Selva Burdette. Selva, Sr., is a maintenance man at American Viscose and it was for this firm 12 years ago that Lew got his start pitching in industrial ball.
Nitro is a town of 3,300 in what is known as Magic Valley, at one end of Kanawha County, just 17 miles from Charleston. It received its name, naturally enough, from an explosives plant established there during World War I. At the town limits signs proudly proclaim it to be 'Nitro, Home of Lew Burdette.'
Burdette- the West Virginians pronounce it BIRD-it, with the accent on the first syllable, although the baseball pronunciation is Burr-DETT, with the second syllable accented- wasn't known as Lew or even Selva or Junior, in his Nitro days. He was Froggy Burdette, a kid who was always carrying a frog or something live in his pocket.
His fourth-grade teacher still recalls- rather proudly now- how he used to drive her to distraction with his unusual pocket pieces. Once he made a pet of a mole-cricket and would bring to school, where the clicking would keep the other pupils snickering.
That extracurricular fun-loving continues to this day. Before a spring training exhibition at Bradenton, Fla., in 1956, Burdette captured a small garter snake and carried in his uniform hip pocket until he found a victim for his gag. He dropped the tiny reptile into the coat pocket of an advertising agency man, then asked the unsuspecting fellow for a match.
His practical jokes, like his pitches, know no bounds. When the Braves were on a train from New York to Philadelphia, he tied together the shoelaces of a snoozing sports writer, then abandoned him to his hobbling fate as the team detrained without him. On a bus trip, when one of the Milwaukee broadcasters was engrossed in a newspaper, Burdette stealthily lit a match to it. As the flames spread, the startled broadcaster dropped the paper. Another section of the paper which had fallen to the floor was ignited. Only prompt action by teammates saved the bus.
One of Burdette's favorite amusements is to harass traffic with his imitation of a policeman's whistle, done through his teeth so shrilly it imitates those of traffic cops. He gets a big kick in scaring passing motorists into believing a cop is on their tail. Once the hurler leaned out of the Braves' bus on a busy Chicago boulevard and made one of his best whistles. Two drivers of adjacent cars pulled over to the curb to await their tickets!
Whether it was conduct like this that brought about Burdette's team nickname of 'Squirrel' or whether it's an abbreviation of 'Squirrel Jaws,' as Lew and his older brother, Les, were known in Nitro, isn't clear. Either is appropriate.
The fact that the Yankees let Burdette 'get away' in their late-1951 deal for Johnny Sain has been well rehashed. (Incidentally, you can't fault the Yankees too much for the deal, for Sain helped them to their 1951-52-53 pennants.) Not so publicized has been the fact that the Braves also muffed Burdette.
When he was pitching for the University of Richmond, a seven-month's term as an Air Corps cadet, a scout for the then-Boston club told him that 'he had no ability and to forget about the game.' The next spring the same scout did an about-face and offered Lew a $100 dollar a month contract, but by this time a Yankee scout had made a better offer and Burdette went to pitch for the Yankees' Class B farm club at Norfolk, Va.
Burdette pitched a three-hit shutout over Lynchburg in his pro debut, but after a few rough innings subsequently, he was lowered to Amsterdam for further schooling. Then to Quincy, Ill., in the Three I League, where he had his one good minor league season (16-11, 2.02) in 1948, and from there to Kansas City, San Francisco and then Boston in late 1951. For the Braves he has won 85 games in his six full seasons.
Just another twist in the story of Lew Burdette, the man of many twists and the little Froggy who, in nine Indian summery days this past October, suddenly became the biggest Froggy in the biggest pond of all."
-Phil Allen, Baseball Digest, December 1957
CAN BURDETTE BEAT SERIES' 3-WIN JINX?
"Most anybody would give his good right arm to be able to pitch three victories in one World Series- and, come to look into it, some pitchers have. Literally. For there seems to be a jinx that endeavors to ensnare the mound's rarest of triads and it gets in its dirty work about half the time.
It's possible to beat down, of course, and here's hoping Lew Burdette does, but the inhuman punishment of powering out pressure pitch after pressure pitch, so frequently and in so short a time, has exacted retribution from such three-Series-winners as Christy Mathewson, Smoky Joe Wood and Deacon Phillippe.
None was the same the year after he did the triple honors; Smoky Joe and the Deacon never were the same any time after that.
Wood was the jinx's choicest victim. He was only 22 years old when he pitched the Red Sox into the 1912 World Series with 34 American League victories and then followed up by personally accounting for three of the four triumphs over the Giants that gave Boston the world title, but he never amounted to much after that big year. Though he was at an age when he should have been at the prime of his career, he dropped from 34 to 11 victories the next season and then to nine the following year. Another season and his pitching career was ended, though he hung on as an outfielder with Cleveland until 1922.
Phillippe also paid heavily for his week of glory in the 1903 Series. He won 25 league games in 1903, but after beating the Red Sox three times for Pittsburgh, he was able to win only ten games the following season, when he was no better than a .500 pitcher. He came back in 1905 with a 20-win season, but wasn't overly successful beyond that.
Mathewson's three big ones in the 1905 Series also called for a reckoning the following season. While he did win 22 games for the Giants in 1906, a collection that would have been a creditable collection for any ordinary pitcher, for Matty it was his worst season in twelve, the lowest victory total for him in any season from 1903 to 1914 and a decided letdown from his 31 triumphs in his triple-Series-win year.
Red Faber, who won three times for the White Sox in the 1917 Series, also fell into a slump after that, but he believes an influenza attack was largely responsible. He did start out fast in 1918, winning four out of five with a 1.22 earned run average before enlisting in the Navy. Rejoining the Sox in 1919, he was able to win only 11 games because of a weak arm.
But Matty, Smoky Joe and the Deacon were called upon to pay off right away for their super-exertion. They really gave their good right arms for three Series wins."
-Harold Sheldon, Baseball Digest, December 1957
"Lew was the sensation of the 1957 World Series. He beat the Yankees three times, giving up only two runs. It was ironic that Lew, who was originally in the Yankees chain, should return to haunt his former bosses.
His fidgety motion bothers batters. Series star Lew baffled the Yankees with his low ball stuff."
-1958 Topps No. 10
"Burdette, a 17-game winner during the regular season in 1957, was the hero of the World Series. He became the first pitcher in 37 years to win three complete Series games. Two of them were shutouts."
-1958 Topps No. 289
SHAGGING OUTFIELDER STORY
"Lew Burdette, the Milwaukee Braves pitching hero of the 1957 World Series, lost an argument during spring training when he was being clobbered by the Dodgers in an exhibition game.
Manager Fred Haney sent Coach Billy Herman out to the mound to remove him for a reliever and the Braves' infield gathered about the pitcher.
'It's only an exhibition. Let me stay in. I need the work,' Burdette begged.
'Maybe you do, but the outfielders are getting more than they can use,' Red Shoendienst, the second baseman, countered."
-Sec Taylor, Des Moines Register (Baseball Digest, July 1958)